As humans, we are always faced with decisions. Some decisions are easier than others, and these decisions carry little to no consequences. However, some decisions can affect others because they are life-changing and, in these scenarios, lead to death. The majority of the time, I think I am very capable of making the right decision. There are situations where there is no right decision, but you have to make a choice, even if it is unfavorable. Deciding between two option is what its called decision making. These decisions can be made through either an intuitive (knowing without much information) or reasoning process (using current knowledge to make a decision), or a combination of the two (Decision Making, 2016). Train Dilemma - Five Children
A train is hurtling down the track where five children are standing. You are the switch person. By throwing the switch, you can put the train on a side track where one child is standing. Will you throw the switch?
In this scenario, a train is racing towards five children. I am the switch person. By throwing the switch, I can force the train to take a path where only one child is standing. Do I throw the switch? Lafollette (2007) suggests that when we begin to theorize about ethics, we find we may not be able to rationally do what we might, pre-theoretically, want to do. Will I throw the switch? My initial reaction to the situation is to throw the switch and sacrifice one to save the five children. Last year I had a major car accident. A young man ran a stop sign and entered the flow of traffic. I had to make a quick decision when the young man couldn't make it entirely across the street. Do I hit him, or do I jump into another lane preventing hitting the young man but cause a four-car wreck? I choose to hit the young man's car to sacrifice the other vehicles. To make better choices, we must become aware of our options and the relevant background information; we should identify the consequences of our actions for others, for ourselves, and for the people, we will become" (LaFollette, 2007).Train Dilemma - Five Children & Elderly Man
You are standing next to an elderly man. If you push him in front of the train it will stop the train, and all the children will be saved. Will you push him?
The second scenario states that if you were to push an elderly man in front of the train, it will stop it and save the children. Once again, there is no right or wrong answer, and the situation goes against my moral and ethical beliefs. Still, if all my resources were exhausted and the only way to save the children is by pushing the elderly man, I would push the elderly to protect the children. According to Hugh LaFollette, "if my behavior harms others, then it is subject to moral evaluation" (p 15). That being said, I would prefer to save all of the people in this scenario, and not push the elderly man, but since that is not an option, I would choose to save the five. As humans, it is our ethical duty to save as many lives as possible in any given situation.
Train Dilemma - Five Children (One is Your Child)
Same scenario except: The one child on the side track is your child. Will you throw the switch to save the five children?
In this scenario, there is no apparent right or wrong answer.
This scenario was eye-opening and made me think about the consequence of my actions because there were only children involved. I certainly hope that I never find myself in a position to be responsible for the death of any child. However, my moral compass would lead me to save my child. LaFollette (2007) suggests that when we are confident about the consequences of our actions, we are more confident about which one is morally correct (p. 10). According to the Cyenfin Framework, scenarios one and two would be a simple decision making context, and scenario three would be a complicated decision making context (Snowden & Boone, 2007, p. 73). While we can hope never to face any of these scenarios, in reality, exercises like these help as leaders when faced with making difficult decisions.
References
Decision Making. (2016). Retrieved March 27, 2016, from http://www.skillsyouneed.com/ips/decision-making.html
LaFollette, H. (2007). The practice of ethics. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
Snowden, D., & Boone, M. (2007). A Leader's Framework for Decision Making. Harvard Business Review, 85(11), 68-76.
